allerFeinst! Shop Test: Is the Spice Trader from the Sauerland Worth It?

Anyone who has stood irritated in front of the supermarket spice rack, wondering why their currywurst never tastes like the one from the local snack stand, knows the problem. The pre-made spice blend costs almost nothing, but it also tastes like almost nothing. Ordering instead from a specialised online spice retailer often means paying noticeably more, without being sure the markup is actually worth it.

allerFeinst! is one of these specialised retailers, positioning itself deliberately between discount-store spices and boutique-manufacturer luxury prices. The shop promises first-class but affordable spice blends, packaged in environmentally conscious materials, produced and bottled in Germany.

What allerFeinst! Actually Is

allerFeinst! is a German online spice retailer operated by Münster und Manz GbR, based in the Sauerland region. The shop positions itself as a team of passionate spice enthusiasts developing new flavour combinations daily, inspired by global culinary traditions, with the goal of offering spice blends that go well beyond the classic pepper-and-salt combination without reaching prices that make everyday kitchen use unrealistic.

All spice blends are, according to the company, exclusively quality-controlled and bottled in Germany, a genuine differentiator, since many competitors in the same price segment have their blends packaged abroad or buy in ready-made recipes from wholesalers. The brand also advertises consistently that it avoids flavour enhancers, fillers, and artificial colourings in its recipes, relying instead on pure spices, herbs, and natural flavour carriers.

Sustainability is the second pillar of the brand identity: packaging runs under the "I am Green" label and uses more environmentally friendly materials compared with classic plastic tins.

What the Shop Offers

For Cooking is the largest category, covering everyday savoury dishes through international specialities: the Air Fry Wonder seasoning salt for air fryers; the Bagel & Stulle Seasoning topping with sesame, fried onion, poppy seed, and fleur de sel; Hawaij, an oriental spice blend for soups and braises; and Flammlachs seasoning in the Finnish style.

For Grilling bundles meat and BBQ seasonings, including a Bratwurst seasoning base, a Chimichurri seasoning for steak and grilled vegetables, and the Premium Roast Chicken seasoning "Mega Mega Chicken," one of the shop's bestsellers.

For Baking includes sweet and savoury baking spices, such as a classic Bread Spice with coriander, caraway, fennel, and anise, and a sugar-free Apple Cake Spice that also works for porridge and oatmeal.

SugarWorld covers sugar and dessert specialities like Liquorice Sugar and a Premium Coffee Spice mocha blend with Ceylon cinnamon, cardamom, and vanilla.

Rescue Me offers reduced or discontinuing products at lower prices. All Spices is the full overview, divided into subcategories including pepper & chilli, herbs & Mediterranean spices, pizza & pasta spices, meat & BBQ, fish & seafood, baking, Christmas spices, salts & basics, sugar & dessert specialities, air fryer spices, international spices, and gift sets.

Value Sets bundle several thematically matching spices at a reduced total price, such as an Oriental Spice Set (Shakshuka, Hawaij, Zaatar) for 19.99 euros, or a Grill Spice Set for 19.99 euros. Most products also offer quantity discounts: buying three, five, or ten reduces the per-unit price noticeably, in some cases by around 33 percent.

The Honest Verdict

allerFeinst! competes in a genuinely crowded German market alongside established names like Gewürzland, Ankerkraut, and Alte Gewürzamt. Available customer reviews on platforms like ShopVote paint a largely positive, if not yet very extensive, picture, with particular praise for fast delivery and good product quality.

Advantages

• The consistent avoidance of flavour enhancers and artificial additives is transparent in most products' ingredient lists, with several blends explicitly labelled glutamate-free.
• All blends are exclusively quality-controlled and bottled in Germany, unlike many competitors who outsource production abroad.
• The range is genuinely broad, spanning everyday German basics to more unusual specialities like Hawaij, sumac, and dried porcini powder.
• Quantity discounts are generous and meaningfully reduce the final price for anyone who cooks regularly.
• The "I am Green" sustainable packaging runs across the whole range, not just a few showcase products.

Disadvantages

• The available review base is still modest compared with established competitors like Gewürzland, which have well over a thousand Trustpilot reviews.
• The per-kilogram base price on some specialty items, such as dried porcini powder, is a real jump from supermarket goods, even if it is standard for the category.
• General experience with German spice shipping suggests occasional carrier delays, though this is not specifically documented for allerFeinst!'s own courier.
• The focus on pre-packaged blends means bulk buyers or professional caterers may be better served by specialised wholesale suppliers.

Who allerFeinst! Is Actually Good For

Home cooks who experiment regularly and value pure, additive-free spice blends; buyers who care about regional production and short supply chains; air fryer owners, given the dedicated Air Fry Wonder seasoning; and anyone looking for a ready-made, easy gift in the spice-set category.

It is less suited to anyone shopping purely for the lowest price per kilogram, who will generally do better at a supermarket or discount bulk pack, with the corresponding trade-offs in flavour and ingredient quality.

How the Categories Differ

For Cooking suits everyday and international dishes alike. For Grilling is especially relevant in spring and summer, bundling everything from basic bratwurst seasoning to more complex rubs. For Baking targets home bakers, with a strong focus on traditional German bread spices and seasonal specialities like gingerbread or speculoos spice at Christmas. SugarWorld is the smallest but most distinct category, best for coffee, dessert, or mulled wine flavouring. Rescue Me rewards price-conscious buyers willing to take discontinuing stock.

How to Save

• Use the tiered quantity discounts consistently: most products offer better per-unit pricing at three, five, or ten units.
• Buy Value Sets instead of individual items for a genuine price advantage plus a ready-made gift idea.
• Check the "Rescue Me" category regularly for reduced, discontinuing stock.
• Compare the per-kilogram base price rather than the tin price, since pack sizes vary considerably between products.
• Use the Highlights and bestseller listings on the homepage as a starting point before browsing the full range.
• Watch the blog and newsletter for recipe content that often points to new or seasonal products.